Hiring the right SEO agency can be a game-changer for your business. But choosing the wrong one? It could waste your budget and hurt your rankings. To avoid this, ask these 15 essential questions to evaluate their skills, strategies, and fit for your business.
Key Questions to Ask:
- What SEO methods do you use? (On-page, technical, link building, etc.)
- What’s your experience? (Years, industries, case studies, certifications)
- What tools do you use? (Google Analytics, Ahrefs, SEMrush, etc.)
- How will you approach SEO for my business? (Tailored strategies, resource allocation)
- How do you research keywords? (Discovery, analysis, implementation)
- How do you handle technical issues? (Audits, prioritization, fixes)
- What’s your link-building process? (Ethical practices only)
- How often do you report progress? (Weekly, monthly, quarterly updates)
- What metrics do you track? (Traffic, rankings, conversions, ROI)
- What’s your pricing model? (Retainer, project-based, hourly, performance-based)
- What are your contract terms? (Notice period, asset ownership, exit fees)
Quick Comparison Table
| Category | What to Check |
|---|---|
| Experience | Years in business, industries served, team qualifications |
| SEO Methods | On-page, technical, content, ethical link building |
| Tools | Analytics (Google Analytics), Keyword Research (Ahrefs, SEMrush), Technical (Screaming Frog) |
| Reporting | Frequency (weekly/monthly), metrics tracked (traffic, conversions, rankings) |
| Pricing | Retainer ($2,500+), Project ($5,000+), Hourly ($150+), Performance-based |
| Contract Terms | Notice period (30-90 days), ownership of assets, post-contract support |
Takeaway: These questions help you ensure the agency is skilled, transparent, and aligned with your goals. Don’t rush - vet thoroughly for sustainable results.
Experience and Skills Assessment
What SEO methods do you use?
Ask about their approach to SEO, focusing on key areas like:
- On-page optimization
- Content strategy
- Technical SEO
- Link building
Make sure they rely on ethical, white-hat techniques that enhance search rankings while prioritizing user experience.
What is your SEO work history?
Key details to evaluate their background:
- Years of experience
- Number of clients served
- Industry specialization
- Team qualifications
- Major accomplishments and certifications
Do you have results from similar projects?
Request information such as:
- Case studies relevant to your industry
- Specific metrics and KPIs achieved
- Project timelines and outcomes
- Solutions they implemented
Be cautious of agencies offering vague claims or unrealistic guarantees.
Which SEO tools do you work with?
Effective SEO requires the right tools for analysis and execution. Here's a breakdown:
| Tool Category | Examples | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Analytics | Google Analytics, Google Search Console | Monitoring traffic and performance |
| Technical SEO | Screaming Frog, GTmetrix | Auditing sites and improving speed |
| Keyword Research | Ahrefs, SEMrush | Finding keywords and analyzing competitors |
| Content Analysis | Surfer SEO, Clearscope | Optimizing content and identifying gaps |
| Rank Tracking | Accuranker, SERP Robot | Tracking rankings and reporting progress |
Reviewing their toolset and methods ensures they have the knowledge and resources to deliver measurable results.
Project Planning and Methods
How will you approach SEO for my business?
Your SEO strategy should be tailored to your specific needs. Here's how a customized process might look:
- Industry analysis: Evaluate your market position, key competitors, and target audience.
- Business goals: Align SEO efforts with your specific objectives.
- Current performance: Review metrics like rankings, website traffic, and conversions.
- Resource allocation: Make the most of your SEO budget for maximum impact.
A personalized plan like this ensures your online presence grows in a measurable and focused way.
How do you research keywords?
A solid keyword research process is essential for effective SEO. Here's how it typically unfolds:
| Research Phase | Actions | Results |
|---|---|---|
| Discovery | Competitor analysis, search intent mapping | Broad keyword list |
| Analysis | Assess search volume and difficulty | Organized keyword clusters |
| Validation | Review SERP trends and conversion potential | Finalized keyword strategy |
| Implementation | Map keywords to content and plan optimizations | Clear action plan |
This structured approach ensures your strategy is built on data and relevance.
How do you address technical SEO issues?
A clear and methodical plan is key to resolving technical challenges. The process should include:
- Site audits: Regularly perform audits using reliable tools to identify problems.
- Prioritization: Rank issues by their potential impact on performance.
- Fix implementation: Address issues in a systematic, prioritized order.
- Ongoing monitoring: Continuously track metrics like site speed, mobile usability, and crawlability.
Key areas like Core Web Vitals, mobile optimization, and site structure should be part of the discussion.
What is your link building process?
Ethical link building is critical for long-term success. A trustworthy agency might follow these steps:
- Content outreach: Develop high-quality resources that naturally earn links.
- Digital PR: Build connections with reputable industry sites and publications.
- Quality checks: Use strict criteria to evaluate the value of potential linking domains.
- Risk management: Avoid harmful links and maintain a clean backlink profile.
Steer clear of promises like guaranteed link counts or tactics involving PBNs. A sustainable, white-hat approach is key to building lasting authority.
Next, learn how agencies keep you updated on progress and results.
SEO Company, Questions to Ask An SEO Agency in 2024
sbb-itb-5be333f
Updates and Progress Reports
Clear communication and consistent updates are key to keeping your SEO efforts on track.
How often do you send updates?
Regular reports help you stay informed about your SEO progress.
| Report Type | Frequency | Key Information |
|---|---|---|
| Status Reports | Weekly/Bi-weekly | Completed tasks |
| Performance Reports | Monthly | Rankings and conversions |
| Strategy Reviews | Quarterly | Goals and adjustments |
| Emergency Updates | As needed | Critical issues |
Most agencies allow you to customize reporting schedules and provide dashboard access. They adapt the frequency of updates to fit your needs while ensuring transparency.
Who manages my account?
Here are some things to consider:
- A dedicated account manager
- A support team for content, technical issues, and link building
- A clear process for resolving issues
- Multiple communication channels with defined response times
Top agencies assign account managers who know your industry and can explain SEO concepts in terms of business outcomes.
What results do you track?
A strong SEO campaign focuses on tracking key metrics, including:
- Traffic Metrics: Organic traffic growth, page views per session, bounce rate trends, and mobile vs. desktop traffic.
- Ranking Performance: Keyword rankings, featured snippet appearances, local pack visibility, and other SERP features.
- Business Impact: Conversion rates, lead quality, revenue from organic traffic, and return on investment.
These metrics align with the tools and strategies discussed earlier, emphasizing data that directly supports your business objectives.
Work Schedule and Output
What work will I receive and when?
A clear work schedule helps set expectations when working with an SEO agency. Here's a typical breakdown of what you might receive and when:
| Timeframe | Deliverables |
|---|---|
| Week 1-2 | Initial audit, competitor analysis, keyword strategy |
| Month 1 | Technical SEO fixes list, content calendar, on-page optimization plan |
| Monthly | New content pieces, backlink acquisition reports, performance analytics |
| Quarterly | Strategy review documents, ROI analysis, goal progress assessment |
During onboarding, agencies should provide a detailed timeline that includes specific tasks, who’s responsible for each, and deadlines. Always ask to review sample deliverables to ensure their quality meets your standards.
When should I expect results?
SEO results don’t happen overnight - they come in stages:
1. Initial Changes (1-3 months)
- Improvements in site performance through technical fixes
- More relevant and higher-quality content
- Better internal linking structure
- Enhanced crawlability and indexing
2. Mid-term Progress (4-6 months)
- Higher keyword rankings
- Growth in organic traffic
- Improved engagement metrics
- Better visibility in local search results
3. Long-term Results (6-12 months)
- Steady ranking improvements
- Consistent traffic increases
- Higher conversion rates
- Greater domain authority
Several factors influence the timeline for results, including:
- The current state of your website’s SEO
- Competitiveness of your industry
- Whether you’re targeting local or national audiences
- Budget and resources for content creation
Be wary of agencies that promise quick fixes or guaranteed rankings. Instead, focus on strategies that build sustainable growth and protect your site’s long-term performance.
Next, take a closer look at pricing and agreement terms to ensure they align with your goals and budget.
Pricing and Agreement Terms
Once you've determined deliverables and timelines, it's time to address pricing and contract details.
How Do You Charge for Services?
Understanding the pricing structure helps you plan your budget effectively. Here are some common models:
| Pricing Model | Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Retainer | $2,500 - $10,000+ | Long-term campaigns, full-service plans |
| Project-Based | $5,000 - $25,000 | One-time tasks like site migrations |
| Hourly Rate | $150 - $300/hour | Smaller projects or consulting work |
| Performance-Based | Base fee + % of results | Campaigns focused on measurable outcomes |
When discussing pricing, make sure to ask about:
- Included Services: What’s covered in the base price?
- Additional Costs: Are there fees for extra work, tools, or content creation?
- Payment Terms: Due dates, payment methods, and late fees.
- Service Tiers: Are there different packages or levels of service?
- Resource Allocation: Who will be working on your account, and how many hours will they dedicate?
What Are the Contract Exit Terms?
Termination clauses ensure both sides are protected and help with a smooth transition if the partnership ends. Pay attention to these key areas:
1. Notice Period
Agencies typically require 30 to 90 days' written notice for termination. This allows them to:
- Wrap up ongoing tasks.
- Document current progress.
- Prepare transition materials.
- Transfer access to tools and accounts.
2. Data and Asset Ownership
Ensure clarity on who owns what, including:
- Content
- Analytics accounts
- Backlink profiles
- Technical documentation
- Completed optimization work
3. Financial Obligations
Be aware of any costs tied to ending the contract, such as:
- Outstanding payments
- Pro-rated refunds
- Transition fees
- Final reporting charges
4. Post-Contract Support
Some agencies offer help after termination to ease the transition. This might include:
- Knowledge transfer
- Historical reports
- Team training
- Recommendations for future optimizations
Before signing, have your legal team review the terms to avoid surprises later. This ensures you're fully prepared for any scenario.
Wrapping It Up
Finding the right SEO agency takes careful consideration. From evaluating their technical skills to understanding their pricing structure, asking the right questions is key to forming a successful partnership.
A good SEO agency should:
- Showcase expertise through case studies and proven results
- Craft tailored strategies specific to your industry
- Communicate openly and consistently
- Deliver detailed reports on progress and results
- Be upfront about pricing
- Clearly define contract terms
The Top SEO Marketing Directory connects businesses with pre-screened SEO providers that meet these standards.
Taking the time to thoroughly vet potential agencies ensures you're choosing a partner who aligns with your goals. This diligence pays off by saving you time, money, and frustration down the road.
